Grand jury indicts 2 white men in dragging death; hate crimes charges still possible

Reported By Jesse Muhammad

A grand jury in Paris, Texas returned first-degree murder indictments against two white men accused in the September dragging death of a Black man. The prosecutor is still looking at whether to pursue hate crime charges in the case that has stirred racial tension.

Facing up to life in prison if convicted, defendants Shannon Finley and Charles Ryan Crostley, are being accused of killing 24-year-old Brandon McClelland by hitting and dragging him over 70 feet beneath a pickup truck after the three went on a late-night beer run across state lines.

Mr. Finley was also indicted December 11 on evidence tampering charges alleging he attempted to wash Mr. McClelland's blood from the undercarriage of the truck. Mr. Crostley was further indicted on charges of retaliation for threatening a potential witness before he was apprehended. Both defendants remain behind bars without bail.

The McClelland family and civil rights groups have been pressing authorities to look into the murder as a possible hate crime based upon Mr. Finley’s rumored affiliation with a White supremacist group that he allegedly joined while in prison several years ago.

“Even with the charge of first degree murder, there may still be a possibility that these murderers of my son will be back on the streets. I want them to have life without the possibility of parole. To never get out”, said Jacqueline McClelland to The Final Call.

“There are people who know that Shannon (Finley) is apart of a white supremacist group and I hope they are interviewed. This needs to be charged as a hate crime also because friends don’t lynch friends”, she said.

Special Prosecutor Toby Shook did not present hate crime charges to the grand jury but noted that "we're still looking at things. You can always go back to the grand jury and reindict."

(Read more about this case at www.finalcall.com)


  1. This is so sickening to me every time I read about this. Seems like you are the only one keeping it consistently in the news.

  2. I honestly think these men should get the death penalty.


What are your thoughts? POST A COMMENT!